Saturday, November 28, 2009

so we're done with catcher in the rye...or are we?

After finishing catcher in the rye my first reaction to the book was not good, i really didnt like the ending, or lack there of one. As I was reading the last few chapters i kept thinking there would be this huge accident or something would happend to Holden that would give you this big "a-ha" moment to the entire book, i waited, and nothing came. i was pretty dissapointed. when i first brought the book home my dad was really happy that i was going to be reading this book because in high school it was his favorite. my mom on the other hand said she still had the cliff notes for it and said she never read past the first few chapters. so i wasnt sure what to expect. i'm probably in between both of them, it wasnt my favorite book but i didnt think it was terrible. after talking to my sister, whoes also reading it, there were a few more things i understood. it was cool to hear about what her class thought on certain things and compare them to what my class had thought. in her class they came up with the mental institution analogy in the first chapter so she's had a different understanding of the book all along. overall though i would give Catcher in the Rye a B or B+ great analogies, bad ending.

4 comments:

  1. I agree with you. It wasn't a terrible book but it wasn't great because I also kept waiting for something major to happen in the end, some sort of tragedy, whether it'd be an accident or a murder. I kept thinking Holden was going to murder someone throughout the entire book because Mr. Kunkle had told us about the relation the book had to previous murderers.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Same! I was expecting that Phoebe would go crazy or something and maybe turn on Holden. The end was pretty dissapointing, but I guess it could've have been worse. And I agree Holden keeps getting more depressed so figured he would just die in the end.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I totally agree with you. I really wanted something big to happen towards the end, but Holden let me down! Even if he would have died at the end, I think it would have made it a bit better.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm definatley done with this book..

    ReplyDelete